|
In
Search of New Marine Toxins in the Magdalen Islands
The
Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA) manages the Marine Biotoxin
Monitoring Program, which is aimed at detecting the presence
of toxins in molluscan shellfish harvested commercially and
recreationally in Quebec. In 1998, the unexpected discovery
of two toxins in molluscs in the Magdalen Islands put CFIA researchers
on the alert and led to a research project with Fisheries and
Oceans Canadas Maurice Lamontagne Institute (MLI). This
article outlines the main findings of the study, which was conducted
under the Human Health component of St Lawrence Vision 2000.
|
|
|
Photo:
Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA)
|
Bivalve
molluscs, which include softshell clams, surf clams, scallops,
mussels, wedge clams and razor clams, are filter feeders. This
means that they suck in water and microscopic algae and extract
the nutrients they need. As a result, molluscs accumulate toxins
produced by algae that can cause illnesses such as paralytic
shellfish poisoning, amnesic shellfish poisoning and diarrhetic
shellfish poisoning in humans.

Rigorous
Monitoring Occasionally Leads to Unexpected Discoveries
Since
large numbers of the algae that cause paralytic shellfish poisoning
are found in the waters off the North Shore, in the Lower St
Lawrence and around Anticosti Island and the Gaspé Peninsula,
the CFIA monitors levels of paralytic toxins in shellfish on
a weekly basis. When the contamination level in molluscan shellfish
exceeds the Canadian standards deemed to be safe for consumers
health, shellfish harvesting areas are closed.
 |
| Alexandrium
tamarense (paralytic shellfish poisoning
toxin) |
The
CFIA also monitors levels of domoic acid, a toxin linked to
amnesic shellfish poisoning. Although very large numbers of
the algae known to produce this toxin are sometimes found in
shellfish harvesting areas in the St Lawrence River, domoic
acid had never been detected in seafood products in Quebec prior
to the summer of 1998, when a routine analysis identified low
concentrations of the acid in scallop gonads.
 |
| Pseudo-nitzschia
seriata (domoic acid) |
Another
surprising discovery awaited Marine Biotoxin Monitoring Program
officials in the summer of 1998. In the Magdalen Islands,
20 people who had eaten mussels showed symptoms resembling
those of diarrhetic shellfish poisoning. An investigation revealed
that the mussels contained small concentrations of one of the
toxins that cause this poisoning, which affects the gastrointestinal
tract. The main symptoms are diarrhea, nausea, vomiting, abdominal
pain and chills. That was the first time in Quebec that a diarrhetic
toxin had been detected in shellfish.

The
Algae Presumed Guilty Already Known to Researchers
The
origin of this toxin seemed to be obvious since MLI researchers
had already detected the presence of the algae that produce
diarrhetic toxins in the St Lawrence, in concentrations
considered dangerous in the Atlantic provinces and in other
countries. Through its toxic algae monitoring program, the MLI
had noted the occasional presence of Prorocentrum lima
in the Magdalen Islands.
On the basis of these
observations, the CFIA and the MLI undertook a study to verify
whether Prorocentrum lima could explain the presence
of diarrhetic (DSP) toxins in Magdalen Islands mussels. They
measured DSP toxin levels in the digestive glands of mussels
and other molluscs in a number of areas around the Islands and
in other parts of the province. There was a 9.9% contamination
rate in the samples. Of this number, 56% had been sampled
outside the Magdalen Islands region, which showed that the contamination
observed for the first time in the summer of 1998 could
affect other harvesting areas in Quebec.
Mussels
accounted for 88% of the cases of contamination and were the
species most affected. The contamination rate among cultured
mussels was shown to be almost four times greater than that
of wild mussels. Samples taken indicated that this difference
might be explained by the use of structures in aquaculture that
provide the Prorocentrum lima with the substrate it needs
to reproduce.

A Newcomer
to the Group of Usual Suspects
Although
concentrations of the toxin produced by Prorocentrum lima
were detected in mussels eaten in the Magdalen Islands in 1998,
it would appear that these levels do not explain the poisoning
that occurred. The guilty party may in fact be Prorocentrum
mexicanum, an alga of the same family whose presence
was unknown in the region. "The presence of Prorocentrum
mexicanum in the Magdalen Islands was completely unexpected
because this alga has until now been considered a tropical species,"
explained Maurice Levasseur, a researcher at the MLI.
 |
 |
| Prorocentrum
lima |
Prorocentrum
mexicanum |
This
discovery added a new twist to the diarrhetic poisoning problem
in the Magdalen Islands. Prorocentrum mexicanum also
produces DSP toxins that cause the same poisoning symptoms.
These toxins were not measured as part of the study conducted
by the CFIA and the MLI, but they may pose a potential
hazard that should be evaluated at a later date.

Toxicity
of Algae Strains in the St Lawrence Studied
A number
of questions arose during the project led by the CFIA and
the MLI. "The next step could be to grow strains of
Prorocentrum lima and Prorocentrum mexicanum found
in the St Lawrence in the laboratory and then compare them with
those that produce toxins in other regions," explained
the CFIAs Gilbert Sauvé. The same type of study could
be conducted with diatoms, which cause amnesic shellfish poisoning.
These algae are sometimes very abundant in shellfish harvesting
areas in the St Lawrence, but no direct link has been established
between their presence and the occasionally very high concentrations
of domoic acid found in molluscs.
By subjecting
algae strains in the St Lawrence to various conditions related
to temperature, light and the availability of nutrients and
observing their ability to produce toxins, researchers will
be able to predict the subsequent increase in their toxicity
following any change in the environmental conditions of the
St Lawrence.
Information:
Maurice Levasseur
Fisheries and Oceans Canada
Maurice Lamontagne Institute
Telephone: (418) 775-0608
E-mail: levasseurm@dfo-mpo.gc.ca
Gilbert Sauvé
Canadian Food Inspection Agency
Telephone: (418) 648-7373, ext 298
E-mail: sauveg@EM.AGR.CA
Sources:
SAUVÉ, G, M LEVASSEUR,
J-Y COUTURE and S MICHAUD. 2000. Évaluation des
biotoxines marines nouvellement identifiées dans des mollusques
du Québec et identification de leurs sources. Canadian Food
Inspection Agency and Fisheries and Oceans Canada, 49 p.
ST-AUBIN,
G. 2000. Bien cueillir
bien manger! La cueillette des
mollusques et votre santé, Comité ZIP de la rive nord de
l'estuaire, 12 p.
|